금 EA의 검증된 실적을 신뢰하기 전에 확인하는 방법
Short answer: To verify a gold EA's track record, look only at a live record tracked by a third party, never at screenshots or a backtest. Check that the account trades real money, not demo money. Count the trades and how long they span. Make sure commission, swap and spread are inside every figure. Read the drawdown on equity, not just on balance.
게시일: 2026년 10월 10일. 마지막 확인: 2026년 10월 26일. 추적 서비스는 규칙을 바꾸므로 그들의 도움말 페이지도 읽어 보세요.
무료, 가입 불필요 판매 중: 월간 패스와 평생 패스. 플랜 보기
Gold EA Checking Kit, $9. Every check from this article, on one page. See the kit
Before a Fed decision
The next Fed rate decision is due on Wednesday, 28 October 2026, at 14:00 Washington time (19:00 Zurich time). In the weeks with a decision, spreads can widen, fills can slip and gold can move fast, so a weak EA tends to show its flaws then. For the full checklist to run before a news day, read How to run a gold EA on news days. No strategy has passed yet; every result is public at baroqtech.com/record.
검증 체크리스트
- Third-party tracked? You need a live tracker link that reads the account directly. Screenshots and "private results" don't count.
- 실제 자금인가요? 계좌 유형이 실계좌(live)여야 합니다. 데모 기록은 다른 것입니다.
- History and privileges verified? Both need to be verified, not just one.
- Enough trades, over enough time? A handful of trades over a few weeks is too early to say anything.
- Costs inside the numbers? Commission and swap should be charged in every figure.
- 에쿼티 드로다운인가요? 청산된 거래만이 아니라 미결 손실도 포함됩니다.
- 입출금이 있었나요? 입금과 출금을 확인하고, 임의의 시작일이 초기 몇 달을 가리고 있지는 않은지 확인하세요. 드로다운 중의 입금은 하락이 얼마나 깊었는지 가립니다.
- Is this the only account running it? Run one EA on many accounts and one of them will look good by chance.
- Close to the backtest? Live results far below what the test promised are a warning.
과거의 좋은 기록은 미래 결과를 예측하지 않습니다. 이 체크리스트를 통과한다고 손실로부터 보호되는 것은 아닙니다.
"검증됨"이 증명하는 것과 증명하지 않는 것
"검증됨"은 추적 서비스가 실제 거래 계좌를 읽었다는 것을 증명합니다. EA가 작동한다는 것, 계속 작동할 것이라는 것은 증명하지 않습니다.
Verified track record: a trade history that a tracking service has read straight from the broker account, usually through an investor (view-only) password. The trades shown are the trades that happened.
거래 권한: 실적을 보여 주는 사람이 해당 계좌를 관리하는지 확인하는 별도의 검사입니다. 권한 없는 내역은 거래가 있었다는 것만 알려 줄 뿐, 판매자의 계좌인지는 알려 주지 않습니다.
각 추적 서비스의 라벨이 확인하는 것
- Myfxbook: Track record means "the account's trading history shown on Myfxbook matches the account's trading history provided by the broker". Trading privileges means "the individual who added the trading account possesses the master password".
- MQL5 Signals: It counts weeks "since the first trade performed on the trading account". It shows the trading mode as "demo or real", and notes that "a provider can afford much greater risks on a demo account than they would on a real one."
- FX Blue: FX Blue sorts published accounts by where the data came from (About FX Blue verification, read 26 October 2026):
- Verified means "FX Blue has collected the account data directly from the broker, using our account sync, or comes from a similar source where the user cannot manipulate the data." FX Blue adds that it cannot rule out a broker manipulating the data.
- Semi-verified accounts "are uploaded using our publisher EAs for MT4 or MT5". FX Blue says the results "are almost certainly genuine. However, it is theoretically possible for users to manipulate the data which is sent to FX Blue."
- Everything else is unverified, including backtesting reports. For those, FX Blue says "it is impossible to verify whether the results have been manipulated, or whether they are from a demo account or a real one."
FX Blue doesn't say that it checks who controls the account. Treat a semi-verified label as weaker evidence than a verified one.
어떤 추적 서비스도 알려 줄 수 없는 것
- 어떤 EA가 거래를 실행했는지.
- 어떤 설정을 사용했는지. 구매하는 버전은 기록의 바탕이 된 설정으로 돌아가지 않을 수 있습니다.
- 계속 작동하는지. 기록은 과거를 설명합니다.
데모와 실계좌: 절대 섞지 마세요
Demo vs live account: a demo account uses practice money at the broker, and a live account uses yours. Fills, spreads, slippage and pressure are all different.
Never add the two into one number. The desk is BaroqTech's MT5 dashboard, and it only reads your account. It shows demo and live on two separate sides, in two colors, and no total ever adds practice money to real money.
기록이 의미를 가지려면 거래가 몇 건이어야 하나요?
A short record can look excellent by luck alone. The fewer the trades, the wider the range that chance alone can produce. If a record is only a few weeks old, the desk's verdict will read "too early", whatever the profit says. That's the minimum for reading a record at all, not a reason to trust one. BaroqTech's judge is the locked set of tests every trading idea has to pass, and it asks for many trades in the period it judges. One idea on the public record, daily momentum, was turned down as "too few trades to judge".
비용 읽기: 수수료, 스왑, 스프레드
Gold strategies often trade short moves, so costs take a big share of each trade, and swap adds up overnight. A record that leaves costs out shows a result the account never earned.
BaroqTech's tests charge spread, commission and slippage on every test trade, plus overnight financing on long positions held past the rollover. They then run again with costs doubled. An edge that only survives cheap trading is not an edge.
Worked example, in words
Picture a system that wins most of its trades with small gains and loses a few with large losses. Once spread, commission and swap come off every trade, the small gains can shrink until the few large losses outweigh them. A high share of winning trades says nothing until the costs are counted.
거래를 올바르게 세는 방법
Partial close: closing part of a position and leaving the rest open, for example taking profit in steps.
One position is one trade, however many times it was partly closed. Counting each partial close as a trade inflates the trade count and the share of winners, while the money stays the same. The desk will merge partial closes into one trade.
위험 신호
에쿼티 드로다운: 계좌 에쿼티가 고점에서 가장 크게 하락한 폭으로, 미결 거래를 포함합니다.
| 위험 신호 | 판매자에게 물어볼 것 |
|---|---|
| 스크린샷만 있음 | "실거래 추적 링크를 볼 수 있나요?" |
| 드로다운 중 입금 | "각 입금 전 에쿼티 드로다운은 얼마였나요?" |
| 매끄러운 잔고, 들쭉날쭉한 에쿼티 | "손실 후에 포지션을 추가하나요?" |
| 실거래가 백테스트보다 훨씬 낮음 | "둘을 나란히 볼 수 있나요?" |
| Record only covers quiet weeks | "How did it trade through the last Fed decision?" |
BaroqTech가 자신에게 같은 규칙을 적용하는 방법
BaroqTech makes quantitative analytics software for gold (XAUUSD) traders on MetaTrader 5, and it holds its own trading ideas to this checklist. Every idea goes through six years of gold prices, the judge (locked tests nobody adjusts afterwards), a demo account, and then a live account with small size, a stop on every trade and a daily loss limit. The full rules are on the method page.
No strategy has passed yet; every result is public at baroqtech.com/record. Each idea is judged on costs, on prices it hasn't seen and on a luck test, and an idea that fails any of them is turned down. Every run is in the log.
The Gold EA Checking Kit puts every check on one page. It is included with the Lifetime Pass.
Related: Why gold EAs pass the backtest and fail live · How to spot a fake gold EA
자주 묻는 질문
EA의 결과가 진짜인지 어떻게 확인하나요?
Ask for a live third-party tracker link, not screenshots. Check that the account trades real money and that both its history and its trading privileges are verified. Then run the checklist above.
Myfxbook의 "검증됨"은 실제로 무엇을 증명하나요?
It proves the trading history matches what the broker provides. If privileges are verified too, it also proves the person who added the account has the master password. It doesn't prove which EA placed the trades, which settings were used, or that the results will continue.
What do "verified" and "semi-verified" mean on FX Blue?
On FX Blue, verified means FX Blue collected the data directly from the broker. Semi-verified means the owner uploaded the data with FX Blue's publisher EA, and FX Blue says users could in theory manipulate that data. Neither label shows which EA placed the trades.
Myfxbook이나 MQL5 시그널 기록을 조작할 수 있나요?
Faking trades is harder than editing a screenshot, but flattering a record is easy. A seller can show the best of several accounts, restart after losses, or present a demo account as live. Ask how many accounts ran the EA.
데모 계좌 실적은 가치가 있나요?
A little. It shows the EA runs as described, but demo fills are usually better than live ones. Results from a demo account do not predict results on a real account.
거래가 몇 건이어야 금 EA의 기록이 의미를 가지나요?
A record with only a few trades over a few weeks is too early to judge. Reaching a larger number is still only the minimum, not proof. BaroqTech's judge asks for many trades before an idea can pass.
Should I run a gold EA during FOMC?
That's your decision, and this page doesn't advise either way. First check whether the EA's record includes past Fed decisions, with costs and equity drawdown shown. Then check that the risk you've set still holds if spreads widen and fills slip.
좋은 검증된 기록이 있으면 EA가 계속 수익을 낼까요?
아닙니다. 과거의 좋은 기록은 미래 결과를 예측하지 않습니다. 기록은 EA를 배제하는 데 쓰고, 선택하는 데 쓰지 마세요.
이 체크리스트를 PDF로 보관하기
아래에 이메일 주소를 남기면 체크리스트가 보관할 수 있는 PDF로 열립니다. 무료이고, 업데이트는 선택 사항이며, 모든 이메일에 구독 해지 링크가 있습니다. BaroqTech는 실패를 포함해 모든 테스트를 공개합니다. 데스크와 가격 보기.
BaroqTech는 소프트웨어를 만듭니다. 투자 조언이 아니며 자금을 운용하지 않습니다. 금 CFD와 같은 레버리지 상품 거래는 손실 위험이 높으며, 전부 잃을 수도 있습니다. 테스트나 데모 계좌의 결과는 실계좌의 결과를 예측하지 않습니다. 전체 위험 고지와 면책 조항을 읽어 보세요.
무료 책 · PDF · 8쪽
트레이딩 로봇에게 던지는 열 가지 질문
점검의 모든 질문을 설명합니다: 좋은 답은 어떤 모습인지, 나쁜 답은 어떻게 들리는지, 구매한 뒤 로봇을 어떻게 시험하는지.